Savannah said, “Your mom thinks Olivia should just disappear.”
Jonathan replied, “My mother talks too much. Olivia doesn’t need to disappear. She just needs to lose everything slowly enough that nobody calls it abuse.”
The file ended.
No one moved.
Even the reporters near the back, who had slipped into the courtroom because Jonathan Reed’s divorce had become quiet local gossip, stopped scribbling.
Victoria Reed’s pearls rested against her throat like a collar.
The judge’s expression was carved from stone.
“Mr. Reed,” he said quietly, “do you recognize your voice?”
Jonathan exhaled through his nose.
“That recording is taken out of context.”
Olivia almost laughed.
It came out as a sob.
“And why were you looking there?” the judge asked.
Ethan’s voice became smaller.
“Because I was looking for my asthma inhaler. Dad took it away after Mason spilled juice on Savannah’s white couch. He said if we wanted to act like babies, we could breathe like babies too.”
Olivia made a sound before she could stop herself.
A broken, wounded sound from the back of her throat.
Denise touched her arm.
Jonathan shook his head.
“That is absolutely false.”
Mason suddenly stood up.
“It’s not false!”
The courtroom snapped toward him.
Mason trembled, but this time he did not sit down.
“He put it in the drawer. Ethan was wheezing and Dad said he was being dramatic. I begged him, and Savannah laughed. She said he sounded like a broken accordion.”
Savannah’s face drained of color.
“That is not what happened,” she whispered.
